Wednesday, April 1, 2015

Session 16: World Systems Theory? Betraying Marxists roots?

The dependency theory which was one of the first structural theories that attempted to explain the dynamics of the International arena. The theory was later developed into the World Systems Theory by Immanuel Wallerstein, who was a sociologist and a historical social scientist. The World Systems Theory breaks the states down into three divisions consisting of the core, semi-periphery and periphery. The division itself show the capitalistic nature of the theory as the division are made according to the level of development of the states. Yes indeed, United States would be considered as a core capitalistic country, exploiting other countries for their own benefits. While on the other hand African states being exploited will be considered as peripheral states

Before we move onto the analysis of fall of capitalism and eventual rise of socialism. It is important to see how effectively the theory explains the international forum. The theory claims that this propaganda of rising capitalism will eventually die down through a revolt which will result in socialism being the new world order. However, earlier dependency theorists have claimed how there can be movement along the hierarchical structure where the peripheral states can graduate into the semi-peripheral. This can be seen as a betrayal to the original Marxists roots as it claims that the proletariat (periphery) will revolt against the bourgeoisie (core) which will result in change to socialism. However, with the possibility of states graduating from the periphery to the semi periphery, then there is little possibility of a major revolt resulting in a total system change.

Moving on from this criticism of the theory itself, it is evident that the theory explains that 
international forum to be capitalistic one where states are looking to exploit other states. The power of certain states gives them leverage over other states which leads to exploitation. The exploitation levels will eventually reach such a stage where there will be no other outcome other than revolt by the weak states against the developed states. As a result, Socialism will then prevail. 

2 comments:

  1. There are many political parties around the globe that have socialist manifestos. Perhaps the idea that socialism may prevail is not at all far fetched.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good post and like that you apply his theory at both the micro (proletariat vs. bourgeoisie) and macro (core vs. periphery) level. But what do you think will happen? Will capitalism survive, or will socialism prevail?

    ReplyDelete