Alexander
Wendt brings up the incredible idea of constructivism as a means of explaining
international relations since he believes that the existing theories of
neorealism and neoliberalism were unable to substantially justify the end of
the cold war. The staunch believer of the model asserts that “the ability to
shed interesting light on concrete problems of world politics must ultimately
test of a method’s worth”. Well clearly, he has added an exciting theory to the
pool.
Constructivism
believes in the power of ideas. He believes that contrary to the notion in the
field to blame the system for violence, states should be held responsible since
the system change ultimately happens through the states. And theories should be
developed to explain the state-centric behaviours. Then he also talks about systemic
approach arguing that though states cannot be studied in isolation, a new
theory should be developed as it will explain certain aspects which the other
theories will fail to acknowledge. He further criticizes realism and presents map
of social theory assumptions and highlights the methodological and ontological
approaches.
However,
this was an interesting piece to read as it was beautifully structured and well
written piece incorporating all the keys ideas that we have studied so far. Discussing
the two schools of thought simultaneously with constructivism helped me better
understand the relatively new theory and assisted me strengthen my grasp on
previous concepts. Furthermore, the author accepts to the level of generalization
and abstraction present in the book which means that he accepts that his work
has room for improvement.
Overall,
constructivism is a pretty fascinating approach and takes the study of IR to a
completely new level by not defining the things to study, but by explaining the
way in which it should be studied. Though it has strengths and weaknesses, it
is still a leading paradigm in international relations field.
Good post and isn't it nice when an author does a good literature review? A good literature reviews allows us to better understand old concepts and relate them to new concepts. With constructivism being a positive concept that is accepted as a major paradigm in IR, it will be an additional theoretical tool for us to use when studying international relations.
ReplyDelete