“War and
Peace” by Jack Levy aims to explain the constant recurrence of war, variations
in war and peace, and the origins of particular wars. Since, International
relations came to be developed as a field sometime between the two major World
Wars it makes sense for it to be obsessed with the issue of War and Peace. The two
although cannot coexist they both are essential to the understanding of the
international system.
The
Realist school believes that the international system is prone to war. The assumption
of an anarchic system coupled with the idea that human nature is evil (thus,
the main cause of war) coupled with the nature of states highlights the system’s
vulnerability. Offensive and defensive leaning of states have also been
highlighted to help comprehend the causes of war.
On the
other hand Idealists believe when appropriate strategies are employed violence
and hence, violence can be significantly reduced. Their main emphasis is upon economic
cooperation between states that will lead to more pacific relations. The WTO
for instance is a forum that unites countries based on their interdependence. This
very interdependence has proved to be a major reason why countries brought
together through trade prefer cooperation over war. Liberalists have also
coined the democratic peace theory according to which democracies are less
likely to fight one another.
As theories put forward by both
the major schools of thought are more or less flawed, Jack Levy proposes the
Multimethod to analyze the prevention of war. This approach incorporates ideas
from both realism and liberalism.
though your argument is valid that countries that are part of WTO would refrain from war but i dont find it a very convincing argument since states can revert to other countries for trade if their relationship with existing partners is compromised. Plus, i think the issue of war is such a sensitive one that states consider a while array of options before indulging in it. However, i like how you have linked it to economic interdependence.
ReplyDelete