Kenneth Waltz, being a perpetuator of Realism, in his
article attempts to explain the structure of the international forum where he
considers states to have a primary goal of self-survival, trying to co-exist
with one and another. He also mentions about the balance of power and how
states are forced to act in their self-interests to maintain or gain more power
over the other states (units). However we already have studied about these
things in the previous classes so there is no need to waste more time on
talking about these particular issues.
One thing which I found very interesting in Waltz piece was
his argument for study politics alone and then observe its impact on the
international structure. The example he gives is a relevant one which states
that when studying economics we don’t consider other factors affecting the
economic outcomes then why cannot we do the same when studying politics and its
impact on the international structure. I agree with his main argument which is
to separate politics from economics and social sciences. It is just like
running a regression in economics controlling for all the other factors to see
the causal effect of the independent variable on the dependent variable. Waltz
argues for a similar kind of technique where we should control for social
sciences etc. when studying politics.
As far as pure theory is concerned, Waltz does give a good
account of how he thinks the international structure should be formed. However,
the main strength of his theory of how to study politics is the practicality of
it where studying politics alone without looking at other effects is not a very
difficult thing to do after all.
But is running a regression analysis always the way to go? There are many drawbacks to big data. Although i agree that structure in itself is a very big causal factor, though very hard to study empirically.
ReplyDeleteWaltz is trying to simplify state behavior in order to explain how the international system works and why states behave the way they do. I think there is value to this, hence I feel like you're being a little to harsh towards Waltz's attempt at explaining the international system.
ReplyDelete