Monday, March 16, 2015

Session 14: 'Stay Unfair. Stay Beautiful.'

Thousands of years ago, Egyptians used wall paintings and papyrus to write messages to communicate with each other. These mediums of communication were also used for sales messages. This form of marketing communication is known as advertising. The main purpose of advertising is to encourage, persuade and manipulate the people into taking a certain action. Advertising is the industry of our time. Also known as “the only true new art form”, it increasingly influences our lives. Although advertising charms many people into buying the products or availing certain services, however, it leads to a negative impact on the lives of many by ideological manipulation, encouraging consumerism and aggressive behavior. 

A major hidden effect of advertising, which people generally find hard to spot, is the presence of imperialist mindset. This concept can be explained clearly with the help of the example of Sunlight Soap. Modern day advertising began because of the Sunlight Soap, the first product of Lever Brothers. The brilliant invention used in addition to the tactfully handled marketing strategies, was the first soap to be given a brand name. The producers of the soap knew which audience to target. They played to the insecurities of the women in Britain and increased their sales. Not only this, Sunlight Soap was also exported to different continents all over the world due its rapidly gaining fame. In a short period of time, Lever Brothers established a monopoly in Congo, Africa. Slowly imperialism started to set in. 

Imperialism is basically the disparate human relationship based on the ideas of mastery and ascendancy. In this case, the white has established supremacy over the slave labor of Africa, which was the black. Sunlight Soap gradually spread to all the British colonies, especially where white dominance was observed. Imperialist tendencies in the colonies were combined with the sale of Sunlight Soap as an attempt by the British Empire to “remove the darkness” from their colonial subjects. The black community in its effort to be like the ‘superior’ class, spent excessive amounts of money on these products. The spread for imperialist powers was fueled by the need for raw materials. This fuels into big Western capitalism and leads to a large scale flow of wealth from the East to the West, just as in colonialism. Modern day fairness creams sold widely in the subcontinent are a reflection of early advertising. These advertisements are not satisfying consumer needs, they are trying to change who the consumers are. Like mice trapped on a running wheel, consumers are caught chasing after a durable satisfaction they cannot even achieve. Even though the era of colonialism is thought to be finished, the presence of these advertisements just reinforces the colonial mind-set. 

Nandita Das, a leading Indian actress and director has started a campaign ‘Dark is Beautiful’ in India, where majority of the population is obsessed with having a fair complexion. This also reflects a form of ideological hegemony eventually leading to problems such as consumerism in the society. 

5 comments:

  1. The consumerist culture mainly strives for material goals in my opinion. What happens is most of the time even after attaining the goals they've set like landing a good job, buying a car or just being better economically then the counterparts; they still feel unfulfilled ultimately. Advertising does just that in my opinion. It sells you an idea of who you ought to be. Which most of us unconsciously buy into and ultimately after the dust settles, realize this is not what we actually wanted in the first place.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I liked your article; I think the reason these advertisements and products do so well is because we have internalized the standards that they are trying to sell.
    For instance, in our country we are big on fairness. In our society fairness, specially for girls, is equated with beauty. And there are SO many examples for this:
    1. Gipsy amazing cream: Gipsy lagao thorri, ho jao gorri gorri (put some gipsy and become fair)
    2. Stillmans: goray goray gaal yeh hai Stillman's ka kamal, o tera kia kehna (fair cheeks! all because of Stillman's! O you beauty)
    3. Fair & Lovely (need I say more?)
    4. Zubaida apa whitening soap: ab gorra hoga Pakistan (Now Pakistan will become fair)

    And countless others.
    I disagree with your point that these advertisements are trying to change who the consumers are; I believe they have already changed us. Which is why the above stated products perform so well in Pakistan. And the worst part is, even though the world has largely moved on from the notion of fairness somehow representing beauty; we, Pakistanis, by and large still believe in the idea.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Aaah yes, the seedy past of consumer culture. Pears and Unilever will have to work harder to erase that. Great analysis, Also, it's interesting to note that Unilever also ushered in the new era of aggressive advertising e.g soap makes you prettier
    http://file.vintageadbrowser.com/193c9vh2kj4qmj.jpg
    or washes away the black http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/randoEMS/Sunlight-Soap_lg.jpg

    They even had the first TV commercial in history by teaming up with the Lumiere brothers.www.youtube.com/watch?v=UxkJbC2-EuY

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great post - your best piece yet. I appreciate you connecting consumerism with imperialism and this quote was great, "These advertisements are not satisfying consumer needs, they are trying to change who the consumers are." Yes, this is the crux of the problem and is one of the reasons why consumerism today in the subcontinent is pernicious.

    Also Kamil and Lyla - awesome comments. Why have we bought into the idea that we can't be happy being who we are? All in all, a great piece and debate.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Only if i could like this post. One of the aims of colonizers was to psychologically coopt the indigeneous minds. Ahsis Nandy talks abouy colonization of the mind in his essay, the intimate enemy and that idea plays well into what you have discussed, how imperialism wanted to civilize and change the outlook of a native.

    ReplyDelete